UFT Delegate Assembly Minutes – November 18, 2026

No commentary, just the minutes:

President’s Report

Michael Mulgrew welcomes everyone. Lot of stuff going on in the State and City.

Federal

National elections. Thanks those who helped. This election was about whether you’re supporting public education or not. Not everyone likes public education in New York. It’s amazing that if you look, especially across the South where public education has been decimated by people trying to privatize, especially in one of the largest states (Texas), this was the issue. We won all of those states except one – Florida. We have to start gearing up for our own fights. Senate is finished. 56-44. Did all the flips. +9. Public education very big in all of those. Tons of governors elected using public education in contentious states. Congress is 259-176. Those are major changes in our national government. I had to attend a briefing. Two issues – affordability. Majority of U.S. feels democracy is under attack. People don’t like rich people controlling what’s going on in the government. Certain mayors have been very rich people. Led to affordability crisis. It’s not party against party or party against people. It’s rich vs. poor. We helped in NYS and people across the country through the AFT. We must keep attacking.

Can’t believe I’m saying this in 2026. We have a measles problem across the United States. A sad, sad situation. Young children dying. Tells us what we’re up against. Here in NY, children need to get vaccines. We’ve lost our status as a measles-free country because of some serious numbers and hospitalizations. We as a country should be ashamed of this. Must care for and help children.

Not in NYS, but across the county public education was a major issue.

State

We want everyone to support public education – democrats and republicans. Want public schools to be supported by City, State, Federal governments, Have majority now. We’re going to need them.

The bad part: Our governor has officially moved us into the voucher program. On The governors who just got voted in are saying ‘no’ to vouchers. When you see an election when there’s a complete repudiation of federal government’s policies, a lightbulb should go off, but no, it hasn’t gone off in Albany. Instead, we get op-eds about how bad we’re doing in public education in NYC and NYS.

Bloomberg is back with money to try to lift charter cap. Goes against all of the national trends from the election. When you start seeing these things – corporations owning media companies, which wasn’t allowed until Clinton – now all of a sudden, it’s hard to get good information. Newspaper stories start popping up across NY outlets. New op-eds. All talking about fixing public education. We’ll see more and more stories about “bad” teachers. It’s all starting again. It’s been a while since we’ve been in a real tough war, but there is one coming. We’ll have conversations we need to have. If they want to waste time and energy, that’s their business, but we’re not going to stop. We’re still cleaning up the freakin’ mess of Bloomberg’s education policies. Consolidations were all his doing.

Getting traction on things we’ve supported. We’re big believers that we should tax the rich. They just got largest tax break from federal government. They don’t want to pay taxes. We pay taxes, they should pay more.

The governor said she wants to take over SED. Someone booed. They got it right,. It’s not easy when multiple people have to agree on education policies. Government built like that on purpose. We don’t want a king or queen. Government by the people. We do not support mayoral control. There has to be a bunch of checks and balances on the mayor if they want mayoral control. Mayor has control, just needs people to agree with him. Not here to tell you SED has worked great for years. Will get into Portrait of a Graduate. Anyone know what it is? It makes your head spin. This whole piece about taking over SED is problematic. Problems will emerge in January-March when legislative season starts. Listening to every elected new governor and congress person and senator all saying we need to protect public education. Why did NYS do this? Sometimes we have to deal with crap. Texas needed a break. They have a good class now. We don’t, but we’ll deal with it.

City

Largest participation ever in our contract survey. I’m never happy with the number but we increased to our largest number ever – more than 40,000 members. We have to move forward. Next meeting is December 9. That is the work of all of you. Social media presence was phenomenal. The teach-ins, crazy memes, thank you.

Thanks District 21 folks for Seth Low meeting last night. Trying to discern what happened. There’s been a change in position from Eva Moskowitz and her team. According to reports from hearing, they don’t want to extend. Conflicts with reports. More charter stuff will come back because more money behind it now from people we’ve been fighting for years.

Class Size – 73% of all classes in NYC are in complete compliance with State law. Not an exemption was needed. Went to a school that asked if they’d get a check. Check was meant to force them to get class sizes down. Knew they wouldn’t do the work without it. The goal here is to get the class size down. They made 73% without an exemption. Phenomenal work. I’ve been in schools. Those who are seeing it are loving it. For chapter leaders – process getting closed where they’ll be sending out to submit for funding for class size reduction will be happening shortly, but not before the next DA. Only 27% of classes in NYC not under compliance. Law is working.

Other things we need to do. Diminishment of enrollment. Still have heavy pockets of overcrowding. Pockets with schools with very low enrollment. But we have the class size law, which we should’ve had decades ago. Also expanded school system by multiple grades. Pre-K, 2K, 3K system helps public education. Lots of people call it daycare. They can call it whatever they want. We’re educating children. Important that parents across communities throughout the City understand they can do that through the publi education system. Not private. When we get into a war, as we did under Bloomberg, who stood side by side with us? The parents. They understood the value and respected public schools. That’s why these things are important,. Will be a tug of war in New York. We’re proud of our school system. Do we like the DOE? Let’s say it this way – we can give them ineffective or developing. Have to give them a TIP. They’re probably hearing this right now. Can’t fix yourself until you embrace the truth.

School consolidations and closures. This is a tough one. Nobody wants this. All of us protect our classes and kids. Reality is, you could’ve went back 15 years ago and figured out this was going to happen. Small schools have failed. Cherry picked which students went to new schools and old schools. Never disrespect the work. Too many schools have too low enrollments. Has to do with number of children in NYC. Constant demographic shifts in NYC. Williamsburg is very crowded. Wasn’t in the ‘70s. Long Island City beyond packed. Parts of Queens – traditional residential neighborhoods – with few school children. So we have a question as a union. We have not helped them do any of this for two decades. Why? Because you’re lying to parents and communities. That’s how they approached this. What’s in the interest of the school? What will we give these children through their teachers? We give it all the time. Small schools often don’t have budgets to do what they want. Our conversations with DOE is “what will your approach be to do this?” What is the reason? What will we offer? How can we ensure situation gets better for you and your students? Not there yet. Some people in DOE have been there for decades and still running it. Have to grapple with. Don’t want charters taking our space. Only school district in state of NY who has to give them space or pay them rent. We don’t want them. This is wrong. When it comes to consolidations and closures, we need to continue to have discussions with DOE. Have to be truthful, transparent, and why things will get better if we do this. Complicated. You can’t say you want to choose specific schools to consolidate when there are smaller schools. Need real transparency.

Biggest new thing – how many mandated trainings do we have to do now? No heads up, they keep popping up. They’re lovely mandated trainings. I know this is tough. Telling every chapter leader – you’re getting an email on Friday. Form you can sign and hand to your principal. I am not saying no to any mandated training – some from state, some from federal govt – coming from Tweed now. Making shit up. We have a work day. In every work day, we have time that is ours. It is the employers’ responsibility, not ours, to figure out how we’re doing mandated training during that workday that’s not during the time when I can do what I want. If anyone has a problem, first let the principal know. Need to know immediately if a principal is saying to you that they can’t do anything about it. All chapter leaders will get that on Friday. I think they have a division of mandated training. We’ll have AI make a webinar. Can train AI to do their paperwork, why not mandated training? Should train AI to watch mandated training. This is the month I try to keep the report – lots of resos popping up, wanna get them out of the way.

Paraprofessionals – The law is in place. Our lawyers – the court has ruled that we’re an official part of this lawsuit – we filed all of our papers. City council filed their papers. Trying to figure out how to make it permanent. There are certain things in the law we put there on purpose. Can only say law is no longer in effect if the City needs the full value of what’s already in the law. Can’t say we’ll only give $3,000. Trying to make it permanent. Horrible incident in Brooklyn. Brutal stuff. But that is not about the paraprofessionals of NY. Another issue – paras on disability pension, Hearing that 20 years ago a mistake was made and now they want to decrease pension for 183 people. People with legit injuries, often by students. Filed a notice of claim with NY. Trying to get to a resolution. We’re not going to sit here and say because TRS and others made a mistake over 20 years ago, these paraprofessionals will have their lives impacted. We’ve started the process.

Portrait of a Graduate – We know Regents are not the only way to demonstrate mastery. Are curriculums giving students what they need to be successful? No. We start with that premise. Now you just pull out your phone and ask it. Children not be prepared if they don’t have critical thinking skills, creativity. List of attributes we all agree on. Public education, social emotional, etc. attributes. In state of NY, it’s either 22 or 44 credits. If you’re a HS teacher, you know what they are. Credits and years are the same. Will children still need to take same basic courses? Yes. Will still have ability to earn Regents diploma. When you hear someone say we’re decoupling the Regents – what they’re saying – is that there may be multiple ways to demonstrate mastery. We don’t take Regents for every course. Regents exams are at the end of a course. This whole thing is being used to attack public education.

** NOTES MAY NOT BE PERFECT BELOW – WAS IN AND OUT FROM 4:55-5:15**

Meeting aggressively with SED. Ammunition to attack us. Can still do regents, capsule project, or project based learning. Where are the rubrics for these things? Need the rubrics. Are we changing standards of NYS? Frustrated. Horrible states moved to because they only require students to graduate at 3rd grade reading level. We have standards for financial literacy and things you don’t think we do. Need community and us to work together. Capstone projects are basically what consortium schools do.

Staff Director’s Report (Mike Sill)

– This Saturday UFT Thanksgiving celebration at UFT. Needs coats. Drop them off at 52.

– Federation of Nurses conference on 11/20, Westin NY Grand Central

– 12/1: world aids day gathering.

– UFT Jewish Heritage Committee dinner dance in Howard beach

– 12/10 event sold out

– Spanish affairs committee holding screening of Delores. Online. Can register on UFT site.

– African American heritage – private celebration at queens office on 12/11

– UFT elementary division. Children ages 3-17 in temporary housing event. Monday 11/23, 12/7.

– Happy belated Veterans Day. Thank you for your service. By my count, there are 128 more days of school. Almost at Thanksgiving. Fake break. Holidays are coming.

Question Period

1: Class sizes. We are the largest high school in the city. Not close to 70%. Struggling. Kids have needs to be in small class like the rest of the city. Our chapter is struggling. Feel left out of the discussion. We need your help. We’re upset and left out. All my classes have 34.

MM: Well said. They thought specialized schools could get permanent exceptions forever. Not in the law. We said, “the school has the number of children it has. Now they need the space to lower ass sizes. Your school has some of the biggest challenges. Can’t be exempt forever. For some reason, DOE thought we’d agree with them to break the law. Not going to happen. Now that we’re at the 73%, they have no choice. I’ll come talk to your staff about that. Have met twice with new heads of SCA. She helped as a parent organizer. From the Bronx. Organized parents throughout the Bronx to get class size on as a ballot initiative. The law is every child in NYC should have this benefit.

2: Heat in classroom. Have to open up windows. Waste of energy.

MM: Almost 70 today and they had the heat on. I recommend you ask consultation committee to have conversation with custodians and principal. We have to teach. The higher you go, the hotter. It used to be that if we don’t use the oil, we don’t get the same amount next year. Only a handful of oil burners left now. If that doesn’t work, talk to us.

3: Low school enrollment. Teachers worked about excessing. If they’re excessed, do they retain tenure?

MM: Yes.

4. MTSS breaking laws for students with disabilities. Teachers not in license area teaching kids. Science and social studies being taken away. Students with disabilities not receiving services.

MM: MTSS not an excuse to break the law. Contact VP MaryJo Ginese

5. How does survey work?

MM: Results go through independent third party. Massive amount of data. Different committees will be formed. General committee is largest. Big issue results. Each group – may not be a chapter – could be D75, CTE, etc. – frustrated with length of survey but it was necessary, Information will all be broken down. Committees formed. That’s the document committees must follow.

Motions directed to the agenda

1: Motion to add a resolution to this month’s agenda. DEDICATED TIME FOR MANDATED TRAININGS

Vote – Yes: 919 No: 29 (online) Yes: 308 No: 9 (in person) 97%. Placed on this month’s agenda.

2: Motion to move the DEDICATED TIME FOR MANDATED TRAININGS resolution up to number 1 on today’s agenda.

Vote – Yes: 809 No: 66 (online) Yes: 273 No: 21 (in person). Placed on top this month’s agenda.

Resolutions

AGENDA ITEM #1 – RESOLUTION FOR DEDICATED TIME FOR MANDATED TRAININGS

Point of information: Why not just enforce the contract regarding time for trainings?

MM: Don’t want to be trapped. Don’t know where a lot of these trainings are coming from.

Vote – Yes: 843 No: 5 (online) Yes: 291 No: 0 (in person) 99.7%. PASSES

AGENDA ITEM #2 – RESOLUTION CALLING FOR ETHICAL SURVEY ADMINISTRATION AND DISTRICT SUPPORT FOLLOWING LOW SURVEY RESULTS

THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, the UFT demands that NYCPS reaffirm and enforce ethical survey guidelines—including prohibitions against coercion, retaliation, or manipulation—and provide mandatory training for school leaders and staff; and

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, the UFT demands that NYCPS establish clear mechanisms for reporting ethics violations with protections against retaliation; and

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, the UFT demands that NYCPS develop surveys for all student-facing titles to gather meaningful feedback on specific roles and working conditions; and

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, the UFT demands that NYCPS respond to low survey scores with timely support and transparent protocols specifying what schools can expect—including coaching, professional learning, climate resources, mental health supports, and staffing assistance—with clear timelines and accountability; and

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, the UFT demands that NYCPS engage school communities in reviewing findings and co-developing improvement plans to ensure meaningful action; and

BE IT FINALLY RESOLVED, the UFT demands that this resolution is shared with appropriate NYCPS offices as a formal call to strengthen ethical practices, data integrity, and district responsibility.

AMENDMENT from NAC’s Michael Shulman – BE IT FINALLY RESOLVED THE UFT AGREES TO ALLOCATE ADDITIONAL RESOURCES SUCH AS CHAPTER ORGANIZER TEAMS, ADVOCACY, KNOWLEDGE, AND INCREASED DISTRICT REPRESENTATIVES TO CHAPTERS SUFFERING FROM ADMINISTRATORS WITH LOW SCHOOL SURVEY SCORES.

Vote on Amendment – Yes: 732 No: 25 (online) Yes: 265 No: 11 (in person) 97%. AMENDMENT PASSES

Vote on Resolution – Yes: 751 No: 18 (online) Yes: 266 No: 3 (in person) 98%. PASSES

MM: Enjoy Thanksgiving… prepare for war!

UFT News – October 2026 (unofficial)

1. Advance observations have likely started or are about to start in public schools throughout NYC. If you look at p.26 of the Advance FAQ (section 2.3.9), it says, “Informal observations may all be unannounced and at least one (1) observation must be unannounced.” This gives chapters some wiggle room to request that teachers be given a heads up on all but one of their informal observations. Admin does not have to agree to this request, but the language in the FAQ allows the opportunity for us to push for fewer surprise observations. Thanks to JP for this amazing tip.

2. Healthcare open enrollment opened on November 1. If you are not enrolled or are looking to switch your healthcare plan, you have until November 30 to do so.

3. NYC is conducting an audit verifying dependents on our healthcare plans. This is referred to as the Dependent Eligibility Verification Audit (DEVA). The City is using Health Management Systems, Inc. (HMS) to run the audit. If you receive a letter from HMS, it’s legit (source: Geof Sorkin’s email from October 17).

4. You likely noticed several emails about upcoming mandated trainings, including the child abuse training that is due November 17. According to the UFT Update email from October 22, “The UFT is currently working to have the DOE ensure that educators are provided time during appropriate professional learning time or, if needed, released from instructional time, to complete all of the many mandated trainings. These trainings should not be done during preps, lunch, OPW time or other professional periods.”

5. The contract campaign survey went out yesterday to active members’ personal emails. The deadline to complete the survey is November 10.

6, If you are asked to participate in an IEP meeting during your prep period, you are entitled to coverage pay. Make sure you let them know up front so it can get approved. There is no coverage pay if you are asked to participate during your C6.

7. Special Education complaints: If there are compliance issues, whether they be students not receiving services, lack of substitute teachers when colleagues call out, IEP issues/violations, or anything else, please file a special education complaint with the UFT here.

8. You can request to view your file at any time. Email the principal to arrange a suitable time. You can have any letter(s) removed three years after the latest incident referred to in the letter. If there is a disciplinary letter in your file that you were never informed of, take a picture of it and send an email to your principal (cc your chapter leader) stating that you want the letter removed. If this happens, be blunt in your email. You can say that you found something in your file that shouldn’t be there and ask them to let you know when to check your file again to make sure it’s no longer there, or else you will file a grievance.

9. Governor Hochul officially turned her back on public schools earlier this month when she opted into the federal school choice tax credit. This is a gut punch that will heavily benefit private schools and take money away from public schools and other projects and programs that would otherwise benefit our communities.

The Math’s Not Adding Up: Part 1 – Para Pay

By now, we all know that there is a severe problem when it comes to paraprofessional pay. Paraprofessional salaries are straight up disrespectful and do nothing to reflect their importance in the school system. Paraprofessionals need to be acknowledged. They are irreplaceable colleagues, often working with our most vulnerable students. To be clear, there is no argument: Paraprofessionals deserve to earn much more money than they currently make. Full stop.

The only controversy when it comes to the topic of increasing para pay is how to get it done. There have been several possibilities floating around in the public discourse. Current UFT leadership is pushing for the Para Respect check, a one-time $10,000 non-pensionable payout that can be renegotiated/renewed from year-to-year. Many outspoken opposition voices have vociferously opposed the Respect check, proclaiming that it’s not enough. They often refer to the $450 million that the UFT used to pay for all members’ retention bonuses as money that could have gone directly to paraprofessionals. There are two glaring problems with this theory that must be addressed. The first is that there is a serious lack of forethought in this proposal, specifically because the math simply doesn’t add up. The other issue is that certain people and groups are pandering to members by claiming the moral high ground and tugging on emotional heartstrings rather than actually surveying members to get their input. Specifically, they take for granted that all titles would be willing to sacrifice their retention bonuses to subsidize raises for paras. We’ll explain why this is a dangerous assumption a little later.

Let’s delve into the math issue first. After all, it’s the least murky of the two. For the sake of argument, we’ll look at what would have happened if the UFT earmarked the $450 million solely for paraprofessionals instead of allocating retention bonuses to all titles. The argument we often hear is that the $450 million could have paid for permanent, $10,000 pensionable raises for paraprofessionals. Mathematically, this could not be further from the truth, and the fact that we have members spouting this publicly to a legion of readers is damaging to the credibility of the opposition.

Ten seconds with a calculator yields the following results: $450 million divided amongst 26,000 full-time paraprofessionals would come out to $17,307.69 per paraprofessional. That money would only be enough to support a one-time payment, not recurring raises. We have opposition folks in conniptions over the Para Respect check when their “solution” – using the $450 million strictly for paraprofessionals – would have yielded only a slightly better outcome that, by their own logic, would not have helped out at all in the long-term.

Providing a $10,000 raise to all full-time paraprofessionals would cost $260 million for a single year. Consequently, the $450 million pool would be exhausted before the end of the second year if allocated toward permanent $10,000 raises. Furthermore, it is doubtful that this $450 million—originally designated for 2024–2027 retention bonuses—could legally or structurally be converted into a permanent salary increase. Standard recurring salary figures remain protected if a contract expires before new negotiations conclude, and it is unclear whether funds drawn from the hard-to-staff pool would count toward baseline figures in future pattern calculations. This also excludes pensionability considerations, which the City would certainly calculate into total costs. Ultimately, the proposal rests on flawed math: whether its proponents know it or not, they are distributing misleading information.

This brings us to issue number two…

Pandering. In a vacuum, giving the $450 million to our lowest paid members would not have been such a bad idea. Some may even say it would have been thoughtful, righteous, and kind. However, we don’t live in a vacuum. Presuming that all active members from all titles would be okay with sacrificing their retention bonuses is a huge ask, especially when members clearly haven’t been surveyed regarding their thoughts on the matter. Although paraprofessionals are the most egregious example, we have members from every single title that are living paycheck to paycheck, or experiencing some sort of financial hardship. Ripping retention bonus money from the pockets of OT/PTs, guidance counselors, secretaries, social workers, nurses, and teachers, many of whom are struggling to meet the cost of living while paying back exorbitant graduate education debt, may not go over too well with membership. I do believe a decent amount of members would be willing to sacrifice their bonuses to help our paras, but I’d also be willing to bet that many members wouldn’t want to give up their money, and plenty of our union brothers and sisters likely can’t afford to take the financial hit. And they shouldn’t be judged negatively for that.

Moreover, using a common fund to raise only the lowest wages creates new inequities for other underpaid members. Unions consisting solely of higher-paid positions, such as the CSA or many uniformed services, do not face this tradeoff. Relying strictly on pattern bargaining to fix wage gaps puts the burden entirely on UFT titles while leaving other unions untouched.

There’s already enough to be angry about. There is no need to make questionable claims that make the opposition look unreliable. What we need to do is work together as a single, functioning unit, to figure out the best way to net our paraprofessionals the raises they so sorely deserve. One-time, non-pensionable payments is not the answer, but neither is pushing solutions that are completely unrealistic.

Disclaimer: This opinion is that of the author and does not represent an official New Action Caucus position.


Learn more about

our UFT Caucus

Content Policy

Content of signed articles and comments represents the opinions of their authors. The views expressed in signed articles are not necessarily the views of New Action/UFT.
Follow New Action – UFT on WordPress.com
November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  

Blog Stats

  • 418,200 hits