Posts Tagged 'UFT Delegate Assembly'

UFT Delegate Assembly Minutes – November 18, 2026

No commentary, just the minutes:

President’s Report

Michael Mulgrew welcomes everyone. Lot of stuff going on in the State and City.

Federal

National elections. Thanks those who helped. This election was about whether you’re supporting public education or not. Not everyone likes public education in New York. It’s amazing that if you look, especially across the South where public education has been decimated by people trying to privatize, especially in one of the largest states (Texas), this was the issue. We won all of those states except one – Florida. We have to start gearing up for our own fights. Senate is finished. 56-44. Did all the flips. +9. Public education very big in all of those. Tons of governors elected using public education in contentious states. Congress is 259-176. Those are major changes in our national government. I had to attend a briefing. Two issues – affordability. Majority of U.S. feels democracy is under attack. People don’t like rich people controlling what’s going on in the government. Certain mayors have been very rich people. Led to affordability crisis. It’s not party against party or party against people. It’s rich vs. poor. We helped in NYS and people across the country through the AFT. We must keep attacking.

Can’t believe I’m saying this in 2026. We have a measles problem across the United States. A sad, sad situation. Young children dying. Tells us what we’re up against. Here in NY, children need to get vaccines. We’ve lost our status as a measles-free country because of some serious numbers and hospitalizations. We as a country should be ashamed of this. Must care for and help children.

Not in NYS, but across the county public education was a major issue.

State

We want everyone to support public education – democrats and republicans. Want public schools to be supported by City, State, Federal governments, Have majority now. We’re going to need them.

The bad part: Our governor has officially moved us into the voucher program. On The governors who just got voted in are saying ‘no’ to vouchers. When you see an election when there’s a complete repudiation of federal government’s policies, a lightbulb should go off, but no, it hasn’t gone off in Albany. Instead, we get op-eds about how bad we’re doing in public education in NYC and NYS.

Bloomberg is back with money to try to lift charter cap. Goes against all of the national trends from the election. When you start seeing these things – corporations owning media companies, which wasn’t allowed until Clinton – now all of a sudden, it’s hard to get good information. Newspaper stories start popping up across NY outlets. New op-eds. All talking about fixing public education. We’ll see more and more stories about “bad” teachers. It’s all starting again. It’s been a while since we’ve been in a real tough war, but there is one coming. We’ll have conversations we need to have. If they want to waste time and energy, that’s their business, but we’re not going to stop. We’re still cleaning up the freakin’ mess of Bloomberg’s education policies. Consolidations were all his doing.

Getting traction on things we’ve supported. We’re big believers that we should tax the rich. They just got largest tax break from federal government. They don’t want to pay taxes. We pay taxes, they should pay more.

The governor said she wants to take over SED. Someone booed. They got it right,. It’s not easy when multiple people have to agree on education policies. Government built like that on purpose. We don’t want a king or queen. Government by the people. We do not support mayoral control. There has to be a bunch of checks and balances on the mayor if they want mayoral control. Mayor has control, just needs people to agree with him. Not here to tell you SED has worked great for years. Will get into Portrait of a Graduate. Anyone know what it is? It makes your head spin. This whole piece about taking over SED is problematic. Problems will emerge in January-March when legislative season starts. Listening to every elected new governor and congress person and senator all saying we need to protect public education. Why did NYS do this? Sometimes we have to deal with crap. Texas needed a break. They have a good class now. We don’t, but we’ll deal with it.

City

Largest participation ever in our contract survey. I’m never happy with the number but we increased to our largest number ever – more than 40,000 members. We have to move forward. Next meeting is December 9. That is the work of all of you. Social media presence was phenomenal. The teach-ins, crazy memes, thank you.

Thanks District 21 folks for Seth Low meeting last night. Trying to discern what happened. There’s been a change in position from Eva Moskowitz and her team. According to reports from hearing, they don’t want to extend. Conflicts with reports. More charter stuff will come back because more money behind it now from people we’ve been fighting for years.

Class Size – 73% of all classes in NYC are in complete compliance with State law. Not an exemption was needed. Went to a school that asked if they’d get a check. Check was meant to force them to get class sizes down. Knew they wouldn’t do the work without it. The goal here is to get the class size down. They made 73% without an exemption. Phenomenal work. I’ve been in schools. Those who are seeing it are loving it. For chapter leaders – process getting closed where they’ll be sending out to submit for funding for class size reduction will be happening shortly, but not before the next DA. Only 27% of classes in NYC not under compliance. Law is working.

Other things we need to do. Diminishment of enrollment. Still have heavy pockets of overcrowding. Pockets with schools with very low enrollment. But we have the class size law, which we should’ve had decades ago. Also expanded school system by multiple grades. Pre-K, 2K, 3K system helps public education. Lots of people call it daycare. They can call it whatever they want. We’re educating children. Important that parents across communities throughout the City understand they can do that through the publi education system. Not private. When we get into a war, as we did under Bloomberg, who stood side by side with us? The parents. They understood the value and respected public schools. That’s why these things are important,. Will be a tug of war in New York. We’re proud of our school system. Do we like the DOE? Let’s say it this way – we can give them ineffective or developing. Have to give them a TIP. They’re probably hearing this right now. Can’t fix yourself until you embrace the truth.

School consolidations and closures. This is a tough one. Nobody wants this. All of us protect our classes and kids. Reality is, you could’ve went back 15 years ago and figured out this was going to happen. Small schools have failed. Cherry picked which students went to new schools and old schools. Never disrespect the work. Too many schools have too low enrollments. Has to do with number of children in NYC. Constant demographic shifts in NYC. Williamsburg is very crowded. Wasn’t in the ‘70s. Long Island City beyond packed. Parts of Queens – traditional residential neighborhoods – with few school children. So we have a question as a union. We have not helped them do any of this for two decades. Why? Because you’re lying to parents and communities. That’s how they approached this. What’s in the interest of the school? What will we give these children through their teachers? We give it all the time. Small schools often don’t have budgets to do what they want. Our conversations with DOE is “what will your approach be to do this?” What is the reason? What will we offer? How can we ensure situation gets better for you and your students? Not there yet. Some people in DOE have been there for decades and still running it. Have to grapple with. Don’t want charters taking our space. Only school district in state of NY who has to give them space or pay them rent. We don’t want them. This is wrong. When it comes to consolidations and closures, we need to continue to have discussions with DOE. Have to be truthful, transparent, and why things will get better if we do this. Complicated. You can’t say you want to choose specific schools to consolidate when there are smaller schools. Need real transparency.

Biggest new thing – how many mandated trainings do we have to do now? No heads up, they keep popping up. They’re lovely mandated trainings. I know this is tough. Telling every chapter leader – you’re getting an email on Friday. Form you can sign and hand to your principal. I am not saying no to any mandated training – some from state, some from federal govt – coming from Tweed now. Making shit up. We have a work day. In every work day, we have time that is ours. It is the employers’ responsibility, not ours, to figure out how we’re doing mandated training during that workday that’s not during the time when I can do what I want. If anyone has a problem, first let the principal know. Need to know immediately if a principal is saying to you that they can’t do anything about it. All chapter leaders will get that on Friday. I think they have a division of mandated training. We’ll have AI make a webinar. Can train AI to do their paperwork, why not mandated training? Should train AI to watch mandated training. This is the month I try to keep the report – lots of resos popping up, wanna get them out of the way.

Paraprofessionals – The law is in place. Our lawyers – the court has ruled that we’re an official part of this lawsuit – we filed all of our papers. City council filed their papers. Trying to figure out how to make it permanent. There are certain things in the law we put there on purpose. Can only say law is no longer in effect if the City needs the full value of what’s already in the law. Can’t say we’ll only give $3,000. Trying to make it permanent. Horrible incident in Brooklyn. Brutal stuff. But that is not about the paraprofessionals of NY. Another issue – paras on disability pension, Hearing that 20 years ago a mistake was made and now they want to decrease pension for 183 people. People with legit injuries, often by students. Filed a notice of claim with NY. Trying to get to a resolution. We’re not going to sit here and say because TRS and others made a mistake over 20 years ago, these paraprofessionals will have their lives impacted. We’ve started the process.

Portrait of a Graduate – We know Regents are not the only way to demonstrate mastery. Are curriculums giving students what they need to be successful? No. We start with that premise. Now you just pull out your phone and ask it. Children not be prepared if they don’t have critical thinking skills, creativity. List of attributes we all agree on. Public education, social emotional, etc. attributes. In state of NY, it’s either 22 or 44 credits. If you’re a HS teacher, you know what they are. Credits and years are the same. Will children still need to take same basic courses? Yes. Will still have ability to earn Regents diploma. When you hear someone say we’re decoupling the Regents – what they’re saying – is that there may be multiple ways to demonstrate mastery. We don’t take Regents for every course. Regents exams are at the end of a course. This whole thing is being used to attack public education.

** NOTES MAY NOT BE PERFECT BELOW – WAS IN AND OUT FROM 4:55-5:15**

Meeting aggressively with SED. Ammunition to attack us. Can still do regents, capsule project, or project based learning. Where are the rubrics for these things? Need the rubrics. Are we changing standards of NYS? Frustrated. Horrible states moved to because they only require students to graduate at 3rd grade reading level. We have standards for financial literacy and things you don’t think we do. Need community and us to work together. Capstone projects are basically what consortium schools do.

Staff Director’s Report (Mike Sill)

– This Saturday UFT Thanksgiving celebration at UFT. Needs coats. Drop them off at 52.

– Federation of Nurses conference on 11/20, Westin NY Grand Central

– 12/1: world aids day gathering.

– UFT Jewish Heritage Committee dinner dance in Howard beach

– 12/10 event sold out

– Spanish affairs committee holding screening of Delores. Online. Can register on UFT site.

– African American heritage – private celebration at queens office on 12/11

– UFT elementary division. Children ages 3-17 in temporary housing event. Monday 11/23, 12/7.

– Happy belated Veterans Day. Thank you for your service. By my count, there are 128 more days of school. Almost at Thanksgiving. Fake break. Holidays are coming.

Question Period

1: Class sizes. We are the largest high school in the city. Not close to 70%. Struggling. Kids have needs to be in small class like the rest of the city. Our chapter is struggling. Feel left out of the discussion. We need your help. We’re upset and left out. All my classes have 34.

MM: Well said. They thought specialized schools could get permanent exceptions forever. Not in the law. We said, “the school has the number of children it has. Now they need the space to lower ass sizes. Your school has some of the biggest challenges. Can’t be exempt forever. For some reason, DOE thought we’d agree with them to break the law. Not going to happen. Now that we’re at the 73%, they have no choice. I’ll come talk to your staff about that. Have met twice with new heads of SCA. She helped as a parent organizer. From the Bronx. Organized parents throughout the Bronx to get class size on as a ballot initiative. The law is every child in NYC should have this benefit.

2: Heat in classroom. Have to open up windows. Waste of energy.

MM: Almost 70 today and they had the heat on. I recommend you ask consultation committee to have conversation with custodians and principal. We have to teach. The higher you go, the hotter. It used to be that if we don’t use the oil, we don’t get the same amount next year. Only a handful of oil burners left now. If that doesn’t work, talk to us.

3: Low school enrollment. Teachers worked about excessing. If they’re excessed, do they retain tenure?

MM: Yes.

4. MTSS breaking laws for students with disabilities. Teachers not in license area teaching kids. Science and social studies being taken away. Students with disabilities not receiving services.

MM: MTSS not an excuse to break the law. Contact VP MaryJo Ginese

5. How does survey work?

MM: Results go through independent third party. Massive amount of data. Different committees will be formed. General committee is largest. Big issue results. Each group – may not be a chapter – could be D75, CTE, etc. – frustrated with length of survey but it was necessary, Information will all be broken down. Committees formed. That’s the document committees must follow.

Motions directed to the agenda

1: Motion to add a resolution to this month’s agenda. DEDICATED TIME FOR MANDATED TRAININGS

Vote – Yes: 919 No: 29 (online) Yes: 308 No: 9 (in person) 97%. Placed on this month’s agenda.

2: Motion to move the DEDICATED TIME FOR MANDATED TRAININGS resolution up to number 1 on today’s agenda.

Vote – Yes: 809 No: 66 (online) Yes: 273 No: 21 (in person). Placed on top this month’s agenda.

Resolutions

AGENDA ITEM #1 – RESOLUTION FOR DEDICATED TIME FOR MANDATED TRAININGS

Point of information: Why not just enforce the contract regarding time for trainings?

MM: Don’t want to be trapped. Don’t know where a lot of these trainings are coming from.

Vote – Yes: 843 No: 5 (online) Yes: 291 No: 0 (in person) 99.7%. PASSES

AGENDA ITEM #2 – RESOLUTION CALLING FOR ETHICAL SURVEY ADMINISTRATION AND DISTRICT SUPPORT FOLLOWING LOW SURVEY RESULTS

THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, the UFT demands that NYCPS reaffirm and enforce ethical survey guidelines—including prohibitions against coercion, retaliation, or manipulation—and provide mandatory training for school leaders and staff; and

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, the UFT demands that NYCPS establish clear mechanisms for reporting ethics violations with protections against retaliation; and

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, the UFT demands that NYCPS develop surveys for all student-facing titles to gather meaningful feedback on specific roles and working conditions; and

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, the UFT demands that NYCPS respond to low survey scores with timely support and transparent protocols specifying what schools can expect—including coaching, professional learning, climate resources, mental health supports, and staffing assistance—with clear timelines and accountability; and

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, the UFT demands that NYCPS engage school communities in reviewing findings and co-developing improvement plans to ensure meaningful action; and

BE IT FINALLY RESOLVED, the UFT demands that this resolution is shared with appropriate NYCPS offices as a formal call to strengthen ethical practices, data integrity, and district responsibility.

AMENDMENT from NAC’s Michael Shulman – BE IT FINALLY RESOLVED THE UFT AGREES TO ALLOCATE ADDITIONAL RESOURCES SUCH AS CHAPTER ORGANIZER TEAMS, ADVOCACY, KNOWLEDGE, AND INCREASED DISTRICT REPRESENTATIVES TO CHAPTERS SUFFERING FROM ADMINISTRATORS WITH LOW SCHOOL SURVEY SCORES.

Vote on Amendment – Yes: 732 No: 25 (online) Yes: 265 No: 11 (in person) 97%. AMENDMENT PASSES

Vote on Resolution – Yes: 751 No: 18 (online) Yes: 266 No: 3 (in person) 98%. PASSES

MM: Enjoy Thanksgiving… prepare for war!

UFT Delegate Assembly Minutes – October 14, 2026

No commentary. Just the minutes…

President’s Report

Michael Mulgrew welcomes everyone to the first DA of the school year. It’s going to be an interesting year.

Moment of silence for UFT Rep Ilyana Frias. Tells an inspiring story about Ilyana and how she fought for us and our students.

Welcomes new delegates and chapter leaders. MM thanks everyone for their unionism.

Federal

The upcoming elections are everything. It’s going to get nastier. We have folks working and coordinating with different groups in NYC, NYC, and nationally regarding election interference. Better to be safe than sorry. We want people to have the ability to vote without being harassed, go to voting stations without issue. Coordinating nationally through the AFT. Phone banks up and running. When we’re doing our political work, we have committees who vet candidates. Vetting done by volunteers. Simple – how do you feel about our profession? Do you support it or not? How do you feel about unions? Collective bargaining? In the end, we give a recommendation. If you don’t want to support it, don’t support it. But if your priority is your profession, the union, and collective bargaining, you may want to listen to our recommendations. If not, vote how you want. Politics are so toxic at this point. If people ask why we’re supporting a specific candidate, it’s to keep our livelihood safe.

National voucher program – It is NOT a scholarship program. We had a big disagreement with our governor. We’ve made our position very clear. I believe the governor believes she can do something no other state can do – I don’t believe she can do it. The regulations came out. They’re clear. The IRS gets to set the rules, not the DOE. Once they set the rules, there is no appeal. State cannot change those rules. We’ve been approached by a lot of different people who want to make sure the money gets to public education. The governor said our state is opting in. It is what it is. Goes back to politics. That is not protecting public education. I want to thank colleagues from Texas. They’ve given us lots of information and data about how it’s hurt public education in Texas.

State

Class Size – Putting together legislative agenda for January. Last October, the main thrust was Tier 6 for legislative agenda. 80 buses to Albany, petitions, and the rest of it. Not done with Tier 6, especially the contribution part and the different numbers they’re using to decide pension. We have a COLA bill for retirees. Ran into serious opposition from actuaries. COLA is not right. It’s at such a low level. Even our friends in Albany, elected officials said we can’t do this cost in our budget. We don’t have the right to argue with actuary, but doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be argued with. Big challenge on COLA and that we want the 8.25% back for the TDA. Comes down to “What does it cost?” I’m fed up with the actuaries coming to affect us. Used to have actuaries there for a very long time. Whether you’re in City, State, hospitals, everyone needs actuaries. This new crop of actuaries are very aggressive and overestimating costs. Those are the challenges we’re going to face in Albany. Currently facing them with NYC actuaries. Paid family leaves was a massive victory. Took 6 weeks extra to fight with them for charging us way too much. Had to keep going in and proving them wrong.

Class Size – If 10 years ago, I said 70% of classes adhered to class sizes the rest of the state has, we’d think it impossible. For close to 40 years, we tried to figure out how to get class sizes similar to the rest of the state. I met someone in charge of the petitions in the Bronx. Loophole that the mayor has the right to remove one resolution. Tried to pass this before but the mayor at the time removed it. The mayor and lots of elected officials didn’t want it. Charter school industry was apoplectic about us getting this law. Two reasons they didn’t want us getting the Class Size law – 1) It cost too much. We got Albany to finally fully fund foundation aid. That was the funding we needed to pay for Class Size. 2) “It’s impossible to do.” They came up with crazy estimates. We told them to give us a law and we’ll make sure it gets done. In the law, it says we have the same authority as the Board of Ed and principal’s union. If we’re not in compliance with the law in any particular year, we lose money. UFT would not come to agreement with DOE about what’s in evaluation law by trying to make us at-will employees. We gave up money to save that from happening. Want to make it clear. We don’t want to do that.

We knew they couldn’t get to 80% this school year because they didn’t have a construction plan in place. We were ready for this. We agreed to help extend this law, only if we get the whole construction plan and how much time it’s going to take for each school. Every plan is not final, but in motion. We will get to 70% this year. The last 30% will be difficult. A lot of it has to do with programming. A lot of it is about the need for new space. Each school should be having a conversation about their class size plan. We don’t want the DOE telling you what your class size plan should be. They don’t know your building. We found out during COVID they don’t even know the size of every school. Class Size law is not about your school, but about the total number of classes. Teachers asking if they’re getting paid for oversized classes. You all need to be on the same page. For this year, the DOE is allowed to have 30% of their classes not in compliance. Last year, a bunch of people looked at their school lists at the end of November. There were questions at December DA asking why classes are exempt on their class size plan. That class was officially used by the DOE to get credit for a plan in place that that class would come into compliance in the next 1-2 years. That can be used for being in compliance for that school year. We said any chance you use towards an exemption for credit to the state means you were irresponsible. As always, you get to put that burden on the teacher, but now you’re going to pay that teacher. It’s only the classes that they’re using as exemptions. We get that list in November. Compliance doesn’t necessarily mean they hit 70%, but that they have a plan to hit it. Percentage from last year doesn’t stay the same. Teachers retired, how many were hired? Wanted 6,000-7,000. Don’t have that yet. Have to wait to see about hiring. Next phase is next year. Supposed to be at 80%. Should be more exemptions next year. If you’re being used as a waiver, you will get paid extra for oversized classes. This goes on forever. We’re going to get this done. We can do this in NYC. The amount of space required isn’t near what was estimated. We still have our contractual limits. The number of classes that even 10 years ago would’ve been about 40%. But now we will be at 70% for this year. We have a lot of people working on this. Every year, it will require maintenance. Every year the DOE will come to us and ask for exemptions. If we find it’s legit, that’s fine, but then those teachers should get a check. Have your meetings with your principals about Class Size. If you need to speak about space, speak about space. We’ll come in and help. Programming changes need to be looked at. After we finish this year, we’re focusing on the remaining 30%. I hear you, specialized high schools. You are not exempt from the Class Size law. We’ll figure out how to create more space.

City

Paraprofessional Bill – Passed. Got a new judge. Parties have an agreement that we are now an active part of the lawsuit. Parties agreed. Will respond with what our arguments should be. Not announcing them here. Want them to be surprised. Trying to make this permanent. Leadership of the para chapter understands everything going back and forth. Frustrating. The DOE lost the argument. Their argument is that it doesn’t matter that we need at least 9,000 substitutes a day. If we have people in the position, then it’s not a vacancy. It’s called a substitute for a reason. It’s a substitute because you need a permanent. You need a substitute every day to make sure it’s taken care of for one day. The DOE was saying we don’t have a problem. We have all the paras we need. 70-80% of DA raises hands when asked if their schools are short on paras. More stress for us and our members. Para bill is in place. Trying to make it permanent.

IRMAA Audits – IRMAA is a process that every piece of software or digital platform that every DOE tech goes through to make through its safe. I’m the employer, you’re using this software with children, I have to make sure it’s safe. Makes sense. But, according to DOE, they made sure every piece of software went through IRMAA audit. Only ones we approved, not the ones in school. That’s why we don’t have access to certain platforms. Magic Classroom is now safe. They knew this. Why would you wait until the second week of school to turn off IRMAA software that did not qualify? Should’ve been checked in July. That’s the frustration. The IRMAA audit continues. Still a couple platforms being utilized. Someone corrects Mulgrew about the name of the program – Magic School.

MTSS – If someone said they wanted to set up a literacy program for schools to help identify if students are on grade level, what their deficiencies are, what we need to do to get them to grade level, we would say fine. But that’s not what we got. We got a mess. In 2021, a regulation about academic intervention was changed. State said you’re not doing what you’re supposed to do. Supposed to tell us about what you’re doing about academic intervention for those that need it. Never mentioned MTSS. DOE studies situation for two years and birthed MTSS. They said we’re going to mess up the entire school system. There’s supposed to be a screener. Fine. We usually do that anyway. First week of school.

**NOTE: I MISSED A LOT FROM HERE UNTIL THE END OF MM’S REPORT. APOLOGIES IF IT’S CLUNKY and INCOMPLETE.**

Don’t know why this turned into Frankenstein’s monster. We do screeners in the beginning of the year, figure out students’ strengths and weaknesses. Doesn’t mean every child goes to level 2.

We can do one academic program in a classroom. DOE thinks we can do 4 or 5. Hurts and confuses children. Teachers need appropriate training and materials. And now they have limits on screen time. Good luck doing this. Parents opting children out of academic support programs. If you had the WIN program before your kids got to school, your admin doesn’t know what the hell they’re doing. Nobody’s been appropriately trained. Schools saying every child needs to be in this thing. Ridiculous.

CEP – nobody’s looking at these. Legal documents. Section 6 covers this. Supplying DRs with that section highlighted. You need to know if a child should be in Tier 2 or Tier 3. We need to start using CEPs to appropriately judge if a child is in Tier 2 or Tier 3. Doesn’t need to be scheduled. Can be done in all different ways, but damage has been done. One intervention program per teacher once they’re appropriately trained and have the materials.

Last week, the DOE sent out guidance for teachers to monitor screen time. Do we let kids turn screens on for Election Day? We’re going to go by COVID protocols. I have no idea what’s going on up there. They’ll say it doesn’t count. We have guidelines for this stuff. Virtual learning during Covid was treated like regular classrooms.

We were trending up. Protecting our school system. They want communities to lose confidence in schools, get frustrated.

Contract campaign is our focus this year. Teach-in the Thursday before Halloween. MM holds vote to see if people want additional contract campaign training for their schools. 

634-223 vote for additional campaign training.

MM: Teach-in leads to survey. Very important. Never use DOE email. Only personal emails. Emails must be updated to receive surveys. Need lots of people responding. More people = more power.

Point of order – will substitute members also get the survey?

MM – Yes.

Staff Director’s Report (Mike Sill)

– CL meeting tomorrow

– Anti-bullying at 9am tomorrow.

– 10/18: Making Strides Walk for Brooklyn, Queens, LI

– 10/20: Toilet learning workshops for Pre-K, 3K, Paras

– 10/25: Making Strides Walk

– 10/28: Third meeting of 750 member negotiating team. 4pm at 52 Broadway.

– 11/12: School secretary chapter meeting on tenure.

– 11/17: HS Huddle

– Toy and coat drives already underway.

– Raffle at the end of DA. Proceeds to Disaster Relief Fund.

MM: Our union is one of the best fundraisers in this country for Strides. We do this with get pride. It’s amazing to see all the schools show up. Thanks to Welfare Fund for the UFT Golf Outing. Money goes to Disaster Relief Fund.

Question Period

1. Today is day 23 of the school year. I’ve had up to 7 mandatory trainings. What is the union doing about that? There’s a lot that needs to be done and we don’t have the time.

MM: Anyone on negotiating committee needs to hear what he just said. The number of mandatory meetings is out of control. Not possible. The employer will say they’re not mandating all of it. City Council and State also mandate training. As long as they make sure training is within our work hours, it’s fine. Don’t tell us to watch mandated Webinar on our own time. Take us out of our classes to let us watch them. I understand the Safety training, especially with our climate. Of course, fire drills are important. But bloodborne pathogens – we get it. We don’t have the time to do it. Either you pick and choose or you pony up the bucks.

2. Class Size law – Keep hearing about the Capital Plan. Will there be another round for schools to apply for funding for additional staff?

MM: Yes. There is a line in your budget that is specifically for Class Size funding. Your school is going to need it. There will be another round this year. Only way we can get it done. Schools need more funding for additional staff.

3. When Chancellor Samuels introduced himself to principals, he doubled down on NYC Reads. Three curricula offered. It’s not developmentally appropriate. Expect us to teach 90 minutes to kindergarteners. What are we doing to defend our students?

MM: 90 straight minutes to a kindergartener. We won’t even let them sit in front of a screen for 90 minutes because we know it doesn’t help. That’s why I say they’re out of their minds with MTSS. If you don’t understand that kids need to play, you should leave the school system. DOE out of control with outside contracts. Very few companies pushing play. Of course we want children fluent on how to use the screen, but don’t want them being damaged by putting them in front of them. Screenings, diagnostics, progress monitoring. Nothing about play for kindergarteners who now hate school. Hate their teachers for doing this to them. What is your school doing? Make sure it’s in your Consultation notes. Consultation notes give us direct evidence.

4. What ia Tier 1, 2, and 3? For Middle Schools: district pushing for stations in middle schools for small group intervention during ELA, but looks like they’re modeling it after elementary, but with a new name.

MM: You don’t need to have WIN periods. Not mandated. Tier 1 = on level. Tier 2 = some intervention. Tier 3 = severe intervention. Hands over to Vaccaro.

MV: Don’t need a Win period. Calling centers “stations” now. Writing stations instead of centers. Pushing hard for Tier 3 to be pull out. Not there yet, but almost there. MM met with DOE last week.

5. Class exemption: Do principals and district personnel have say in exemption checks? Example: 7th grade teachers get money, but 6th grade teachers don’t.

MM: We have this conversation internally. Money can make colleagues angry at each other. We’re getting there. We’re going to get there. We fought for this law. They’re not happy about this law. Tried to get the law stalled. We’re the UFT, you’re the City. Changing mayors doesn’t mean you get a do-over. As a union, we’re responsible for our actions. You’re the City of New York. New mayor supported Class Size. No do-overs because his people at the DOE say it’s tough.

Motions directed to the agenda

1: Motion to add a resolution to this month’s agenda. RESOLUTION IN SUPPORT OF INTRO 1008.

MM interrupts to clarify: This needs a two-thirds vote. Person can present motion, not motivate it. If you wanted it for next month, then you only need for majority.

Speaker #1 continued: Time limit, I’m proposing this to protect retiree health benefits. Retiree health benefits and collective bargaining go hand in hand. Able to protect wages, healthcare, future retirement benefits. When we think about this legislation, this addresses healthcare for Medicare eligible. For union to negotiate future benefits for future members. We do not have to choose between protecting benefits for retired and those who can negotiate later on. Legislation should establish a floor of protection, not a ceiling on collective bargaining.

Vote – Yes: 653 No: 127 (online) Yes: 259 No: 31 (in person) 85%. Placed on this month’s agenda.

2. Janella Hinds moves to reorder agenda so agenda item #5 (reso to support NYS legislation to prohibit use of victim intoxication as a defense in sex crime cases) is moved to the top.

Vote – Yes: 518 No: 242 (online) Yes: 224 No: 56 (in person) 81%. Moved to number 1.

Resolutions

AGENDA ITEM #5 (moved up to #1) – RESOLUTION SUPPORTING NEW YORK STATE LEGISLATION TO PROHIBIT THE USE OF VICTIM INTOXICATION AS A DEFENSE IN SEX CRIME CASES

Resolved, that the UFT will promote member conversations to destigmatize sexual violence; and be it further

Resolved, that the UFT will lobby in conjunction with NYSUT to pass New York State Senate Bill S.54-A.

Speaker objects to voting. Cites Amy Arundell incident in with an image of her face was placed in a urinal with the caption “Piss on my face” at 52 Broadway during last year’s DA under Mulgrew’s administration.

Second speaker says this isn’t about Amy, but about young men and women who are victims.

Vote – Yes: 703 No: 51 (online) Yes: 250 No: 17 (in person). 93%. PASSES

Ends with raffle.

The Contract Looms: UFT Delegate Assembly, 5-17-2023

Summary/Analysis: There was a packed agenda at the May DA. I can only offer a few words of summary and analysis, as my own schedule is equally packed. Here that goes.

Outside the DA, volunteers from United for Change handed out flyers with our five big demands before we concede a yes vote for any new UFT contract. Inside the DA, Mulgrew started with his usual summary of what’s happening in the State/City. We heard about the asylum seekers, and as of now it looks like they will not be housed in schools. We heard more on budget, including potential federal default and the unfortunate potential expansion of charters via the state budget. We then heard more on the ‘contract countdown.’ Unity is clearly in full on ‘get a yes vote’ mode, but adding some caveats to lower expectations. Weirdly, Mulgrew seemed to try and taper expectations on workplace issues and offer hope on the financials. But we aren’t going to beat DC37’s 3% – not by much. That’s been stated time and time again by his own lead negotiators at Executive Board meetings.  So if the hope Mulgrew is offering isn’t false, I’m lost  – especially since we clearly have no intention of striking. On the other hand, Mulgrew’s framing of the DOE on curriculum issues was very good. My only caveat is I personally (not speaking for New Action) would much rather see UFT fighting to have teacher ‘veto power’ over curriculum. UFT accepting city-wide curriculum mandates is acquiescence to our deprofessionalization.

During the new resolutions period, resolutions about Florida and the U.S. Supreme court were put onto the agenda. During the special order of business period, we passed the second of the NYC City Council endorsements. The resolution passed after an odd and somewhat hypocritical amendment, which supplanted all other debate. Using the old Unity trick to ‘bring all questions before the house,’ no debate ended up happening on the vast majority of candidates. Yay for democracy? As for the endorsement process before DAs, if anyone is interested, I sat on the hearing for who to endorse in CD1 a few weeks ago and offer my full thoughts here. There were also resolutions on other striking unions (not us of course, we’re ‘Taylor Law Proud’), the budget, and maternal mortality. In closing, I’ll note quickly that something seems off about the agenda order. Newer resolutions written by UFT staffers are inexplicably there burying older ones drafted by rank-and-file teachers. But, I’ll save dwelling on that for another time.

Informal Minutes Follow.

President’s Report:

Mulgrew: Asylum seekers. Constant challenge this school year. One group doing the work supporting asylum seekers are those in the schools. No plan of support, regardless of what they say. Have had dozens of schools – teachers running clothing drives, food drives, to help students/families. Now we see 150 cots dropped into a school gym. If it’s a last resort and we have a plan, sure. But it is NOT the last resort, it’s the easy thing for the City to do. We’ve contacted all over. No one is doing their jobs. Not a political issue for us, part of our daily lives. Armories all over, but under state control. Etc, etc. Not the time to say schools are the last resort. Simple things you have to do. First thing people want to know is have their been background checks. Yes. Second, are these standalone sights? Apparently, that has been part of this, but fine – who is handling safety for the asylum seekers and the kids. We need answers on things like this and things like impacted programs. No one talked to parents, why they’re upset. We officially filed for impact bargaining and still had to raise a ruckus to get a conversation going. In the next few days, we’ll find that they probably won’t use the school sites. But it’s the constant politicizing – crisis = schools. No! It has to be the last resort. Education is secondary for these children at this point, and we’re caring for them. If it’s the last resort, we’re OK, but we need questions answered and better communication. Only one building that’s been occupied, and we support these families, but City needs to do a better job. We’re here to help, but we need a plan.

Federal budget: defaulting on all debt? Hoping they figure this out. State level, session not over. Pushing with NYSUT and M. Person to get charters not expanded among other things.

City budget: people who we do business with all the time. The fear right now is that this administration will use the migrant crisis to torpedo the City budget. Important that the federal government does send money to NYS/NYC for doing this work. Most money is going to southern states, who are sending migrants to us. Still a lot of money inside of the NYC reserves. It’s about working with City Council. We had our breakfast 2 weeks ago in this room. All of our advocacy is out there. Other thing is, the City is supplanting State money. We get money from the state, they take it from education at the city level. So we are looking at the state to make a maintenance of effort or nonsupplant clause in all education funding. This has to stop. We’d be in a much better place if we got the right funding.

You have to start talking to people about city council elections. We need city council to stand strong with us.

Contract update: Rallies on the 24th. We are trying, both us and the City, to get this done before the end of the school year. If there’s anything new that needs to be implemented, we need it done then. The overall piece here is that we’re sick of having our time wasted and micromanaged. The only way to keep driving at that is keep doing the public events. The rallies are about elected officials also understanding this. This isn’t just about a little extra attendance work – micromanagement is an issue all over the country, but especially in NYC.

Class Size: City says class size should not be an issue. Some disagreements. We have a law, this isn’t a negotiation. It’s the law of the state, so you must comply to have 20% of all of the classes in our school system from next year period. Not my individual school, district, it’s 20% of all classes in NYC. Should be based upon economic need. So if you have a school with high economic need, those schools need to start doing the work right now. We have a list of these schools, so does the BOE. It’s all out in public. Now the clock is ticking – because the state budget has ended, so they have 30 days. Problem is we don’t know what document they’re putting out. They write political documents about how they don’t have money, but they do, they just keep supplanting it. Overall, your principals – you should be having these conversations.

Curriculum: One union we’re closest to is CSA. (Audible groans and laughter). Their feeling is the DOE won’t give the money for class sizes and then blame them. Our feeling is they should be out their demanding more money so they can comply with the law. That’s why it’s stronger than having it in the contract – it’s the law. First announcement with this mayor and chancellor – a curriculum initiative. Let’s go back 30 years. Every school district did whatever they wanted and it wasn’t working out so well. You can go back further, but for now, 30. There was no incentive for a mayor to fund education since they had no control – not that we support mayoral control – but we were woefully underfunded, had to do many lawsuits. We had scandals all over the place. It was often about the politics of the school district rather than child’s education. Then we went to a strict system of mayoral control. Now it became every school does whatever it wants. This is a perfect strategy if you set up a system where it’s never your fault. At that point, they sold a bill of goods to the public / CSA – you do whatever you want, we hold you accountable. DOE became an accountability system and nothing else. There you go. Then for last 23 years, we’ve been under that system – and it hasn’t been working well for us or the students. Some places, it works; other places, it doesn’t for a variety of reasons. Throughout all of this, the DOE, none of this was their responsibility, since they technically weren’t in charge. So, when the chancellor came to me and said he wants to do this – a phonetic based literacy curriculum. We have all these different systems. Schools can add onto the system we choose – we’ll give some autonomy. Mulgrew says UFT will support that if there is a training regimen. But there have been some real difficulties. DOE’s knee jerk is to hire a vendor. After 23 years, a bureaucracy not having to do any work, this is what we get. So we’ve been going back and forth. Our two vice presidents, Karen and Mary, have been working with them. We’ve gotten to a point where we can support this. Not saying it won’t be rough. So this is a big endeavor. Chancellor said that principals can’t have complete autonomy – you’re doing what I’m telling you to do. CSA didn’t react well at all, which is their business. They haven’t been reacting well to anything since then. But if they use that anger to sabotage things that will be good for our kids, that’s another issue. Some principals have said it’s a fad, or don’t throw away your curriculum, etc, etc. But, the idea here is something we haven’t done for over 30 years – we have a school system taking responsibility for the entire school system. We’re having all the CLs and superintendents for the 15 school districts, in this room, on next Tuesday. There will be vendors, but there will be teacher center all over this. Some credit to DOE: they started taking apart what the vendors have sent them and analyzing it. So this is a real program that we’re trying to take this challenge on. Will there be problems? Yes. 15 school districts would be the second largest in the country – it would be the size of Chicago combined with LA. Large challenge.

Saturday, we had to close registration for spring conference. We always get people walking in and it’s sold out. It’s gonna be a nice day. If you already registered, going to have a good time.

Staff Director’s report (LeRoy Barr):

Was gonna mention the spring conference, but it’s sold out (applause). Thank you for making sure our members signed up. Tomorrow is Haitian flag day. Celebrated each year on May 18th to celebrate Haiti’s independence from the French. Rallies on May 24th at 3:00 PM. We are in all 5 boroughs. Make sure to come out and bring folks out with you. Teacher appreciation week was last year. Was also national school nurse day and administrative employees on April 26th. CLs thank you for updating your consultation notes. We’re in May, so make sure you upload the 9th one. Being told that there are t shirts outside for you, so assume you’ll be wearing them when you come to the rallies. (applause). Goal is to raise 5k for the AIDS walk on 5th/72nd st this weekend. 5k run on Saturday, June 10th on Coney Island. First Book event at PS154. We give away books to students who come out. Juneteenth second annual walk, June 19th, Monday, have off, gather here at 52 Broadway and walk across the Brooklyn bridge. Next DA is on June 7th.

Question Period:

Dave Barry: In Feb. we passed a resolution on the Amazon workers in Kentucky. Currently, a few members have been removed as trainers. So we said in the reso we’d do things to help out. Took me a little while to find the resolution on the website, and we also said we’d donate money, so what’s the progress? What’s the AFT going to do on that? Are we putting it on social media?

Mulgrew: Yes, donations have been made. We’re working with the AFT. For next month, can get you more information. So, there’s a national effort to support these folks. Can get directly to you. In terms of emails, we send out a lot, so twitter is probably the way to go. If we send out too many emails, nobody likes it. Starting to see a shift as people think about things as workers.

Barrows: Calendar! Haven’t seen it yet. How will that affect SBOs, PTCs?

Mulgrew: Clerical day for this year is a clerical day. It’s not a PD day. Folks who have it get it to do their clerical work. If not, we will make a grievance and get you paid. Now on the calendar: many things that happen every year that require us to come to an agreement to move on to the next year. We’re having a hard time coming to agreements, probably as a result of other conversations we’re having. That’s all I’m saying.

Alexander Stimmel: Clarity about what we can talk to our members about in terms of what’s being negotiated. We haven’t heard much about money/raises, etc.

Mulgrew: Let’s just say, we’re far off. There’s a lot of people in our union who like to write about pattern bargaining. We can find ways around it. Our focus has to be to get as much compensation in our members pockets, not give back anything, and get relief from the craziness. Because, our profession…we have openings in every borough. We’re dealing with what the rest of the country is going through, and it’s not going to get better unless we get the right pay and respect. Micromanagement is disrespect. This constant ‘control your day each and every minute,’ no autonomy as a professional who dedicated their lives to helping children. Some sick people. We know about what’s happening in Florida, about policies that are failing. That’s what has to get stopped. That came across very broadly – one of the top issues for every chapter: stop wasting our time; stop the micromanagement. More than a third of our time is wasted by stuff that has nothing to do with our job. Yes, money is the number one priority, but this other stuff is important also. I’d like to do something creative.

Seth Gillman: Budget at the federal level. Federal gov rolling back money not spent on COVID. Don’t want to see money sent back.

Mulgrew: One thing that OMB should do quickly is spend the COVID money. Now, there’s been a large reduction in COVID money. So, it shouldn’t be an issue for us here in NYC.

Allison Kelly: How do the contract negotiations affect the SBO process? If they aren’t finished in time for the contract, how does that affect us with election buddy/etc.

Mulgrew: Real thing holding us up is calendar and workday. Think I answered that as best I could (read between the lines). If we do anything that affects the SBO…we hopefully can get the SBOs done within the next few weeks. We can always have provisions to have new votes in September, reopen processes. We’ll figure it out. What we’d like to do, if we have good conversations, is get the majority of SBOs done by the end of the school year.

Julia (d75 OT/PT): Asking about continuing education issues we’ve had – not been able to take classes remotely, been told we have to show up at school, even though scheduling issues. We get 1400 dollars for continuing education which we need for a license, but it’s been hard to get approval/reimbursement, so some have waited over a year to be reimbursed for classes. Remote classes / freedom of classes would help. Sometimes we’re asked to tie it to kids on our caseload, even if we have different caseloads next year.

Mulgrew: On consultation agenda. It’s gotten ridiculous for several titles. Can change to make this a free for all. Idea was classes should be germane to work, not students on caseload. Nothing about no online classes. Maybe bureaucrats are mad they have to go to school.

Julia: We have 3000 therapists, it’s different to get the approval. So where is the money going if we can’t use it?

Mulgrew: Next Tuesday, consultation, I’ll follow up. We had some interesting discussions with the groups who approve these classes. That’s the nicest way to put it right now. Everyone is now focused on this is broken and has to be fixed. Why not allow remote classes?

New Resolutions:

Margaret Joyce and Barrows: Attacks on public education and public employees unions in Florida. This month’s agenda.  In response to legislation being passed that’s attacking public education and unions. It’s trying to weaken collective bargaining rights. It impairs existing contracts and has constitutional issues. It has book banning, CRT banning (which is only taught at the college level anyways), and school vouchers (which are racist in origin by funneling away money from public schools where students are most protected from discrimination, and test scores aren’t even better). Unions have to now recertify to have 60% membership rate. If it’s less than 60%, they become bargaining agents.

On this month’s agenda: 82% yes.

Name missed: Resolution opposing overreach of the U.S. Supreme Court and its conservative agenda.

On this month’s agenda: 77%.

Resolution Period:

Mulgrew: Endorsement time, let’s have some fun.

See resolutions here.

Liz Perez motivates endorsement reso. We take this very seriously, come with a good heart, have a union who wants to protect our members. These folks vote for our protections. True, we might not always agree. The work we do every day – these folks can help us to reach our children the best way we can. We need the right people in these positions. We’ve done our work/due diligence. These candidates have been vetted, and we need to stand behind folks who will do right by us.

Lamar Hughes: Would like to propose an amendment. Wish to include Christopher Bay as an endorsed candidate for District 19 in Queens. Bay was also a candidate for the D19 seat. There was a lot of dialogue about conversations on who we should endorse. Members on the screening committee were informed, but we believe it’s in our members’ best interests to include both. Going forward from here, it’s time to gear up – we have to unseat the person in D19. They are not our ally. That individual has been disparaging to us. So, with pride and pleasure, I say that Christopher Bay should be included with Tony A. Members should have the opportunity to include both.

Mulgrew: Clarifies – same party, the goal is to do the general. Then there will be another endorsement for the general.

Point of Information: Ranked choice voting? Yes.

Barbara S.: It doesn’t make any sense. Can’t make a choice between two people and decide you want both. If we have an incumbent who is positive for us, then we look at the incumbent and choose them. If we say they’re wrong, then we select one person or another. We cannot say we like two. What happens if there are three? If there are three you like – don’t even make an endorsement. To select both, this makes no sense. Think it’s bad policy – decide who you like the best. Either say no to the incumbent and go to the challenger, but you cannot select two.

Point of information (Mary V.): The two candidates are not the incumbents. Vicky Paladino is?

Amy Arundel: Vicky Paladino is an enemy of public education. We had a rigorous process where we interviewed. We’re saying leave it to members of those 2, then we’ll get behind one of them.

Ilona Nanay: I thought last DA we tried to add a name to the process and were told no, it’s not the process, so I don’t understand what’s happening.

Mulgrew: That’s not what happened…Oh, we did explain…

Barr: At the last DA, the maker of that particular amendment asked us to endorse someone who was still in conversation at the local level. This is different. We’re trying to honor that process. That was a lot of conversation about moving behind both of these democratic candidates, so they can take on the incumbent. The other person was trying to short circuit it and not follow the recommendations of the process.

Question called on all matters of the house.

Mulgrew: That will be for the amendment and the resolution as it stands at that moment.

85%: debate ends.

Amendment vote: 72%, passes.

Resolution as amended: 79%, passes as amended.

Resolution in Support of the Writers Guild of America:

Janella Hinds: 2 weeks ago on May Day, 11,000 members authorized a strike. Wasn’t taken lightly. Shut down production. They’ve taken the decision to strike. Total cost of their demands is hundreds of millions of dollars, but the corporations make billions of dollars. In the time of the strikes, many of these companies have lost billions of dollars. Just one of them could have met the demands, but this is not about austerity, it’s about breaking the union. We as educators have to stand strong. I ask for your support.

Dave Kazanzky: Only thing I love more than looking after your pensions is watching TV and movies. No reason that the writers should provide millions of dollars of revenue and create views and talk about their work and not be able to make a living doing it. Doesn’t make sense doing it. Stand in support.

Martina Meijer: While I am very pro-union, I don’t support this reso, because our union is free to tweet whatever we want. Not sure why we are pro-strike for other unions, but not for ourselves. This is not the right forum. The use of parliamentary motions like in the last motion (City Council) is wrong.

Name missed: No time have I heard we wouldn’t stand up to strike. Tell me your strategy – so don’t come to the floor/table unless you have one. Where is yours so we can stand together?

James ?: Calls question.

86%: passes.

Mulgrew notes that it was the last endorsement. Thanks members who have done the work.

Budget Resolution:

Ilona Nanay: asking folks to support. Show of hands for people who lost staff due to excessing. Nervous about next school year? Many hands up. This resolution is important. A budget is a moral document that demonstrates priorities. We have revenues that have gone up. We finally received foundation aid. Still in the midst of a pandemic and slowly coming out. Schools are vital to the community. Calling the UFT to ask the DOE not to cut budgets next year. We’re also asking for funding to be restored.

Janella Hinds: We worked together and collaborated. This is a statement from the entire high school division of the executive board.

Passes: 98% yes

Resolution to Reduce US Maternal Mortality Rates

Karen Alford: What do Beyonce and Serena Williams have in common? They’ve experienced complications during/after child delivery. What should be a joyous time is not for many. Women are bleeding out and getting infections, dying. There are complications during delivery/childbirth. This is a problem exacerbated for black women. We had the opportunity in March as part of the Black History Film Series to watch Aftershock. It’s there that a spotlight was put on. On April 13th, Biden proclaimed black maternal health week. This was necessary and defined during this week, from the white house, black women are 3-4x more likely to die during pregnancy during pregnancy. Bringing this here today because our moms are worth it. Think of children who are still here but whose lives are lost. We have to stand up. Must be attention shown in reference to maternal health disparities. So stand with us as a body to make sure that women leave hospitals and are alive to care for children.

Passes: 94% yes

Mulgrew: On the 24th, everyone will be out there, doing what they need to do.


Learn more about

our UFT Caucus

Content Policy

Content of signed articles and comments represents the opinions of their authors. The views expressed in signed articles are not necessarily the views of New Action/UFT.
Follow New Action – UFT on WordPress.com
November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  

Blog Stats

  • 418,217 hits